THE CASE FOR LOWER MULTIFAMILY CAP RATES
BY BY MARK SCOTT DECEMBER 8TH, 2012
Attend any number of multifamily conferences around the Tri-State region and cap rates are sure to be a topic of discussion. But while many suggest that cap rates for multifamily rental properties will flatten in the future or even rise, I would argue that they can (and likely will) go lower. There are number of factors driving this compression, including a healthy amount of cash that is ready to return to the market; record low interest rates; and a desire among both Generation Y consumers and the Baby Boomer generation (some 76 million strong) to forgo homeownership in favor of renting. But what’s arguably most important to the cap rate debate will be the fate of the home mortgage interest deduction.
First, let’s follow the cash flow. There is a strong stable of Real Estate Investment Trusts that have large amounts of cash they are looking to deploy, and multifamily is currently the most stable asset class available. In September, the Multifamily Production Index (MPI), released by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), improved for the eighth consecutive quarter with an index level of 54. It is the highest reading since the second quarter of 2005. The MPI, which measures builder and developer sentiment about current conditions in the apartment and condominium market on a scale of 0 to 100, rose from 51 in the first quarter to 54 in the second quarter.
We have seen top-quality multifamily rental product trade anywhere from a 4% to 4.8% cap – an indication that this product is indeed favored by investors. This rate is not entirely surprising given that these are best-in-class buildings that will certainly see rents rise. However, we are also seeing an increased interest among investors looking to purchase older product at a lower basis since there is ultimately more upside following either a cosmetic renovation or major rehab. For these value added investment opportunities, expect to see cap rates decline. What’s more, the low interest rate environment could also dip cap rates even deeper, and it appears that this will remain in place for the next several years. In September, the Federal Reserve announced that it would keep interest rates near-zero well into 2015 even if the economy starts to recover.
One of the most significant factors driving multifamily rental rates is a multi-generational trend toward leasing and away from homeownership. Specifically, Generation Y consumers who have been hit hard by the recession may not be able to purchase a mortgage, and many enjoy the convenience of urban rental space. The Baby Boomer generation is also pursuing rental housing, as many Boomers look for living options that require less personal maintenance or seek to convert their home equity into much-needed retirement income. At a recent speech at the Operation HOPE Global Financial Dignity Summit in Atlanta, GA, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke noted that “homeownership rates [which have slipped nearly 4 percentage points from their 2004 high of 69%] have declined because fewer households have chosen, or have been able, to become new homeowners in recent years. Buying a home usually means obtaining a mortgage, and the data show that the pace of mortgage lending has fallen considerably on a national basis.” He goes on to note that the reduction in mortgage originations and home purchases for “all groups relative to the pre-crisis period partly reflects weakness in the effective demand for housing rather than the unavailability of mortgage credit, with unemployment, income loss and income insecurity preventing many households from purchasing homes, and concerns about the future direction of the labor market, housing prices, and the economy more generally keep other potential buyers on the sidelines.” In the meantime, these groups are providing a hefty boost to the apartment rental market, which should drive down cap rates.
But the biggest wildcard in this whole cap rate debate might just be the home mortgage interest tax deduction. The current deduction, which is lauded by most homeowners, allows them to remove the interest they paid on a mortgage. However, flat-tax advocates favor terminating this deduction, and U.S. lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have been discussing a variety of tax reform structures that could involve the elimination of the mortgage interest tax deduction. Ultimately, if Washington is successful in reducing or eliminating the interest deduction, the multifamily rental market will grow stronger, which could herald in an era of even lower cap rates.